Sat 28 Jun 2008
Atlanta Police too busy to fight real crime
Posted by shelbinator under Culture, Get physical, Local News, Mobile, Politics, Rant, Video
UPDATE: Go join in the fracas over at iReport.com, where this video has gotten over 48,000 61,000 107,000 121,900 views since posting on CNN.com’s front page Saturday afternoon. Clearly there is not enough real news being iReported.
If you were robbed, mugged, or otherwise assaulted or injured in the downtown Atlanta area between 6:45 and 8:00pm on Friday, we bicyclists do apologize for your lack of police protection. You see, we were busy occupying about a dozen motorcycle cops and several police cruisers with our monthly bike ride.
Two months ago when I filed my Choose or Lose story on Critical Mass, I made a specific point to mention that our local police force was actually rather cooperative with us cyclists compared to other cities. I had seen numerous videos before of uncomfortably hostile encounters between cops and Massers in San Francisco (the city of origin), Chicago, and New York, and I had had numerous conversations with Atlanta riders about how nice our local PD was to us. In the downtown area, where police were frequently out on the street directing traffic for tourist destinations, conference attendees, and sports fans, they often stopped cross traffic long enough to get the whole Mass through (and, blessedly, out of their way).
That warm and fuzzy relationship is apparently over. Last month, reporter Stacy Shelton wrote up Critical Mass in the AJC, and apparently someone at City Hall knows how to read. Whoever this literate person is wasn’t about to tolerate any civil disobedience in their fair city, and they ordered the police force into action. Here you go, in video form:
Before we had even gotten past Centennial Olympic Park — maybe half a mile from our starting point downtown — we were intercepted. A phalanx of motorcycle cops was poised on the sidewalk, ready to disrupt the ride. Apparently, only one of them had any cojones, because only a single cyclist was pulled over and ticketed for running a red light. The rest of them must have been too busy oogling the cleavage on wheels or something.
Once we had ridden past, the blood returned to their heads and they managed to figure out where we were going. We saw a few of our law enforcement friends again in Midtown, but things were pretty hunky dory until we crossed over into Virginia Highland and headed south toward Little Five Points. As we approached North Avenue heading south on Highland, the phalanx reappeared out of nowhere, cutting the Mass in half at Manuel’s Tavern and giving pursuit to the front half, which went another quarter of a mile before turning east on Freedom Parkway. By the time the rest of us caught up, the bikes were dismounting the pavement and running up the grass onto the pedestrian path along the Parkway; the motorcycle phalanx and a few cruisers had stationed themselves along the roadway leading up to Moreland.
And then they stood there. (See video.) Some of the braver and/or more confrontational cyclists kept on riding down Freedom Parkway while the rest of us rode in parallel on the walkway, watching (and in several cases, filming). The cops just stood there on their bikes, glaring, like it was some kind of staring contest (or perhaps a who’s-got-the-bigger-wang testosto-fest). They didn’t leap into action as we began to spill back onto Moreland heading south, but perhaps that’s because we came to a stop and in many cases signaled our turns. Or maybe we were in West Side Story, who knows.
Another motorcycle cop was waiting for us a quarter mile later in Little Five Points, as if expecting orders from his Parkway brethren on which one to pull over and ticket. We stopped at the light and then turned right/west into the residential neighborhood to get out of their sight. A much thinner, slower, more fragmented Mass headed down Sinclair for Inman Park.
We didn’t get far. The Freedom Parkway boys found us again at Austin and Elizabeth, and they did a pretty good job of clusterfracking the intersection of Highland and Elizabeth up themselves in an effort to make sure we all observed the stop sign.
Here’s the thing: when you have 400 cyclists out at one time all deciding to take the same route, it’s really in your best interest to let them all pass at once, sacrificing a red light or two if you must, rather than demanding we all stop and look left, right, and left again. Instead of almost a half a mile of solid bikes on the road, you’ll have three miles of two abreast. You want really that?
We made it several more blocks down Highland before the motorbikes raced ahead of us and basically formed a roadblock at Highland and Randolph. So we stopped — losing a number of us to Johnny’s Pizza — and turned left/south on Samson. By the time I caught up with what was left of the Mass at Samson and Irwin, there were a handful of cops there making sure we came to a complete stop and looked both ways before crossing.
The group finally built up some momentum again on Edgewood, but not as much momentum as a dozen or so police officers who just realized how much fun it is stalking and hassling bicyclists. A couple of their motorbikes came whipping past us again and managed to get to the front of the group in time to pull another cyclist over to ticket him for a traffic violation. The rest of the hundred and change cyclists left erupted into whoops and applause as these two brave officers were reinforced by one, two, three, four more motorcycle cops in order to enforce the law on this dangerous commuter-terrorist. A couple of police cruisers pulled up behind and alongside us, so that when the light — keeping us frozen in law abiding stillness while red — turned green, they could use their fancy loudspeakers and bark, “Move along! Move along!” And as it turned yellow again a couple of siren-whoops reminded the eager to stop at the broad white line.
I don’t know if the cops pursued what was left of the Mass all the way back downtown; I turned back at that point to get a beer with friends who had peeled off in Cabbagetown, not wanting their first Critical Mass to result in legal action. But this was definitely a strategic prerogative from on high. In all of my rides with the group, I have never seen such prominent police interference, and in all of my life in Atlanta, I have never seen such police organization, never seen so many cops in one place at one time with such well-timed serendipity. They were all out there just to pursue us and hassle at opportunity. They were reasserting the city’s power after Shelton’s article had made so public how intolerably open-minded they had been to people who actually wanted to do something about our oil addiction. Boy oh boy, did those big mens with their bikes and guns show us.
So, yeah, sorry if you actually needed a cop while we were out riding bikes. They were too busy keeping you safe from the Monkeywrench Gang.
Tags: Atlanta Police, Critical Mass
Read more filed under Culture, Get physical, Local News, Mobile, Politics, Rant, Video
36 Responses to “ Atlanta Police too busy to fight real crime ”
Comments:
Leave a Reply
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
Pingback from Creative Loafing Atlanta » Fresh Loaf » Blog Archive » Blogger: Police shadow Critical Mass bike ride
June 28th, 2008 at 11:42 am[…] Shelby Highsmith (who blogs as Shelbinator) reports yesterday’s Critical Mass group bicycle ride around Atlanta was shadowed by more than a dozen […]
-
Pingback from Atlanta Police Collide With Critical Mass « Decatur Metro
June 30th, 2008 at 10:42 am[…] has the first hand account which includes a video with lots of flashing […]
-
Pingback from arc of time » Blog Archive » delays? what delays.
July 29th, 2008 at 8:34 am[…] you want to know why you can’t get sympathy when something like this happens let me give you a classic […]



June 28th, 2008 at 12:09 pm
gah it’s not like you guys were out during full blown rush hour. i’d love to get my hands on an emergency department response time report from our courageous apd for that time frame. kinda makes you go hmmmm.
June 28th, 2008 at 12:50 pm
This makes me want to buy a bike and partake in these outings.
Really, violent crime is on the rise in this city (which is contrary to the trend nationally), and this is how the police spend their time?
June 28th, 2008 at 1:36 pm
Remind me before the next ride — I may burgle some homes while all the cops are busy following you.
June 29th, 2008 at 3:22 am
No, the police did not follow the group down Edgewood. I did not see any police past the intersection where the ticketing led to applause.
One of the officers who gave a warning to the crowd at Moreland stated that all traffic violations would result in the cyclist’s vehicle being impounded, a hefty fine, and something else I couldn’t understand. I think the word ‘physical’ was part of the description. I’m not sure if any of these threats were carried out.
June 29th, 2008 at 10:21 am
thank you for posting. I’m going to find the next mass in philly and participate.
June 29th, 2008 at 4:26 pm
Traffic laws are there for everyone’s safety. By breaking the law you risk injuring yourself and others. I can’t count the number of times I’ve seen a bicyclist blow throught stop signs and red lights barely missing being hit by a car of hitting a pedestrian. If you want to be respected, then be respectful, obey the laws, including the one where BICYCLISTS MUST YIELD TO PEDESTRIANS.
June 29th, 2008 at 4:40 pm
“Pedestrian,” you are making the same mistake as so many other closed-minded nay-sayers by conflating two vastly different circumstances. Critical Mass is not about saying bicyclists should not ever have to obey traffic laws; for the most part, the majority of riders in CM obey the rules of the road as much as any jackhole Atlanta driver. A lot of us really frown about those who flagrantly (and recklessly) disregard them; in fact, over on the local bike enthusiast website fastermustache.org, there was a discussion going on yesterday about how bikers who hop back and forth b/w road and sidewalk are often careless fools who make the rest of us look bad.
However, when we do this one little monthly ride, that comes and goes from any given neighborhood in about 15 minutes on a single Friday evening each month, the circumstances are different. I’m sorry man, but one contiguous mob of bikes that blocks cross-traffic when it can’t clear an intersection in a single light cycle, that is not the same as the “number of times [you’ve] seen a bicyclist blow through stop signs and red lights.” You’re right, those guys are dicks. But I think it’s a stretch to compare those incidents to Critical Mass. And I think it’s also a stretch if you think that doesn’t happen far, far more often with automobiles driven by road-raging idiots gabbing on their cellphones.
June 29th, 2008 at 7:49 pm
Whether or not you agree that Critical Mass is a good thing or a bad thing, it’s clearly a bad decision for the APD to waste time chasing cyclists around.
I wish they’d spend a tenth as much effort hunting down the bad guys in my neighborhood.
June 30th, 2008 at 12:49 am
In the battle for the title for the title of Biggest Nitwits, it’s neck and neck between the Atlanta PD and the Critical Massers…
June 30th, 2008 at 7:29 am
Actually Brian, it’s a three-way dead heat once you include all the impatient, whining, anti-evolution automobile supremacists coming out of the woodwork to vent their hostility to the video on the internet.
June 30th, 2008 at 12:43 pm
No, they’re not. You cannot pick and choose when the laws apply to you. They’re there for a reason. And whether it’s one cyclist blowing through a stopsign/redlight or 400 of them, you’re making the rest of us look just as bad (or worse) than any fool hopping on and off the sidewalk.
I bike for fun, and I bike to commute. Critical Mass and entitled asses like you are not exercising your rights, you’re flagrantly violating the rules and causing a disruption. And it’s not making it any safer for any of us.
June 30th, 2008 at 1:07 pm
We have a ride every week in Los Angeles and every week we break the law, the very same laws that are there to protect you from the cray people behind the wheel. For you to say that CM riders obey the law is not only wrong, it is an out and out lie. The whole point of a ride is to disrupt traffic and be a pain in the ass.
June 30th, 2008 at 3:11 pm
Jack, you have no idea what an entitled ass I am. But to all the bikers who think that keeping to ourselves, keeping our heads down, and being meek is the only way to change the status quo by setting a “good example” — well, we’re still dying in the streets, so how the hell is that workin’ out for ya? Congressman John Lewis told us once that in order to change the status quo, sometimes “you must get in the way, you must get in trouble.” Write us all the tickets you want, I say, but sometimes it takes losing a bloody green light for the “entitled asses” behind the wheels of their environmentally and economically unsustainable cars to wake up and smell the bikers. I’m sorry you don’t like our tactics, but not sorry enough to stop.
Riderzz, I meant most of us obey the law the other 718 or so hours a month, not during the 2 hours of the ride.
June 30th, 2008 at 4:32 pm
Not so well, thanks. And I maintain that it is, at least in part, due to shit like Critical Mass that angry motorists have such hatred for us.
In fact you do not say. The whole point of your initial post was to whine that you should be allowed to break the law once a month without those pesky police officers bothering you. If a similar “demonstration” were held each month with cars or motorcycles riding 6 abreast all over every lane of the road and breaking as many other rules as you guys do (but, hey, it’s only one little ride a month!) I doubt you’d be as accommodating to them.
If raising awareness is really your goal, surely there must be a better way to do it, that doesn’t completely antagonize the more heavily armed opposition.
June 30th, 2008 at 5:14 pm
Well, Jack, I guess that’s where we just fundamentally disagree. I think there were crazy, angry, and more importantly just plain careless drivers out there well before, and totally independent of, Critical Mass. As both sides will stipulate, I think, the bigger problem is the small fraction of Crazy Bikers who ride crazy the other 29 days a month, but that’s a separate problem that we’re working on within our own population, and is not germane to this particular conversation about the CM ride itself. The number of irate motorists that we encounter on the CM rides is really quite minuscule. Most are bemused, puzzled, sometimes laughing, some waving; we also pass by hundreds upon hundreds of people enjoying happy hour on patios and try to spur them into dusting off that bike in the garage. So, I guess it’s a question of whether you think the math is effective: do we activate more bikers and remind more drivers to watch out for us than we alienate drivers who might be more inclined to intentionally run us over because they’re already freaking psychopaths? And I think if most of the CM riders didn’t think the answer was yes, they wouldn’t do it, because the number of the bikers in the Mass that are the obnoxious Crazy Bikers is rather small.
As for my whining, I’m just pointing out that surely, surely in this city that is bucking the national crime downturn trend with our uptick in violent crime, the po-po would be better off doing something other than issuing a few tickets. I may be a Democrat who likes paying my taxes, but damn, use ‘em wisely.
And I am not opposed to any traffic-blocking parade of any particular mode of transportation, and I’d have no animosity toward any such group that paraded with the same joie d’vivre and sense of fun that CM takes with it. Seriously, the warmth we encounter from people far outweighs the road rage, and I thought it might be something special about Atlanta compared to other cities. It’s like being Baton Bob for a day. Dude, I live by Piedmont Park; my mobility is constantly interrupted by road races, parades, festivals, Screen on the Green (when there’s no drought), etc, and I don’t get all ‘roid rage about it. Life is too short, and my butt is too small to have such a big stick up it.
Happy Friday, man! Happy Friday!
June 30th, 2008 at 6:37 pm
Jack McGhee,
You remind me big gigantic piece of poop steaming up a phone booth.
Suck it,
Sam
June 30th, 2008 at 6:41 pm
Made of Rubber Sammy boy, made of Rubber. I am a rider and Jack is 150% right!
June 30th, 2008 at 6:45 pm
Sammy girl, Riderzz, and she is 150% hot! She kicked cancer’s ass up and down the mountain and I’m sure she’s still got plenty of whupass left. :-)
June 30th, 2008 at 7:55 pm
Yes, I really do. Critical Mass aims to increase awareness of bikers, right? I would argue that a 3-mile string of bikers is much more visible and reaches more motorists and pedestrians than a small mass a couple blocks long. And then if a group of ‘roid raging drivers gets an attitude about said 3-mile string, so what? You’re not breaking any rules and you every right to be there.
Check out this article about last month’s CM in New Haven, CT. Apparently two riders approached the cops in advance and worked out a plan to have traffic corked at each intersection along the path. Could this work in Atlanta? I don’t know. But I challenge each and every CM rider to do what they can to LEGALLY promote bikes as a viable, legitimate form of transportation on the streets, and keep the spirit and awareness of CM moving forward.
June 30th, 2008 at 10:06 pm
riderzz,
you are a gigantic poop defender.
stinky stinky,
sam
June 30th, 2008 at 10:17 pm
ok, so now I’ll make one comment that doesn’t have to do with third grade boy poop humor.
If it weren’t for civil disobedience I wouldn’t enjoy many of the freedoms I have in this country. The first that comes to mind is the right to vote. I am a woman. This country wouldn’t thrive if it weren’t for are foremothers and forefathers who fought, questioned and changed the laws. Why is it that that certain individuals are always trying to silence that energy and passion. All these folks want to do is ride their bikes en mass so they can be seen by motorists. It blocks traffic for like five minutes a month. That is a fraction of how often traffic is blocked for other things like UPS trucks. But UPS trucks have a purpose of profit.. so society tolerates it. The society won’t tolerate that group which questions they way they live, in their gas consuming machines. They don’t understand two wheels and they do what they can to shut it off. Same story different day.
Plus I’d like to point out that if I stay on my bike and scotch between cars that are stopped at a red light, jump ahead of them and go when it is clear but still red, I’m half a block ahead of traffic when it turns. That is much safer for me and everyone else to be ahead rather than mixed in. If I stop at a four way stop sign on my bike, everyone just gets confused and it takes longer for the cars to get through. If I keep my eyes and ears open slow down, look the driver of the stopped car in the eye, I can usually tell if he is going to let me through or go, if he goes, I cross behind him, if he waves me through I cross in front. It is much faster, more efficient, and safer for everyone if I don’t stop at the stop sign.
June 30th, 2008 at 10:21 pm
Shelbinator,
Im not sure why, but for some reason you remind me of that ‘dont taze me bro’ guy. Just keep your camcorder handy… I need another good laugh.
-Empiricus
June 30th, 2008 at 10:36 pm
Empiricus, I am totally guessing here, but it might be due to your being an idiot. The don’t tase me bro guy was a douchebag. I am a smartass. Big difference.
July 1st, 2008 at 2:44 am
I wish they would have ticketed all of you. I don’t get to get together with all of my buddies on friday and decide we’re all going to drive through all the stoplights in town. Who died and left y’all to believe you’re the kings of the road? Every single one of the riders in this disgusting display of lawlessness would run crying for a cop if their precious little bicycle was stolen, because they would want the law upheld in that case. The laws are the laws. You don’t get to pick and choose which you obey and which you don’t.
July 1st, 2008 at 7:46 am
Shelby,
You should change the subtitle of your blog from “more fun than watching crack grow” to “a disgusting display of lawlessness.”
July 1st, 2008 at 11:51 am
Takes one to know one?
I don’t even know what to say back to you about the rest of it. Nothing you’ve described is any safer than waiting your turn and following the rules, it’s simply more convenient for you. You are the Crazy Biker 30 days/mo. Eye contact or not, weaving in and out of traffic, cutting in line, running stop signs, etc, is exactly the kind of stuff that makes car drivers hate us because you are completely unpredictable in the road, and just when they finally pass you, you zip ahead at a stop light and they’ve to to deal with you again in half a block. I just don’t understand how you don’t see that at all.
I mean, do whatever you want, obviously nothing I say here is going to change your mind or ways. Just don’t go bitching to CNN when you do get hit and those pesky cops determine it was 100% your fault :)
July 1st, 2008 at 12:45 pm
That is a MF’ing fantastic idea, Rusty.
July 1st, 2008 at 3:55 pm
Jack, Are you telling me that you’ve never ever not once gone through a stop sign or a red light on your bike? Are you telling me that every time you approach a stop sign you stop and put your foot down? Every single time? Even if there are no cars around? Even if you are at a four way stop and the car in opposing traffic is stopped and waving you on? ARe you going to stop because you don’t want to break the law? How about if there is another car going in the same direction as you and your riding along side of him in the bike lane… do you stop even though you KNOW the car perpendicular to you is not able to go anywhere? Do you really? How about if in that situation you know that if you stop you will only be holding up the driver that is behind the car you are next to?
I never said I weave in between traffic wildly. I said that I’m efficient and don’t wait for a traffic jam just because there are too many cars on the road. And yes, if I get hit and injured or killed because of some asshole not paying attention to me then I absolutely will be pissed off. I probably won’t cry to CNN though because CNN is not my deal. All of these people posting here about how the bicyclist deserves to be hit or hurt or arrested and thrown in jailbecause they participate in critical mass is maddening. It is unbelievable to me. It’s a fucking bicycle. We are not terrorists. And for that matter, don’t we have a right to assembly in this country? It’s civil disobedience.
And if you think you are less likely to get killed because you stop at every sigle stop sign you’re wrong. They are going to rage against you for holding them up. They are going to still have to pass you if you stay with them. You are just as vulnerable as me. You’re just on a higher horse and you think I deserve to be killed because I roll through stop signs if all the other parties are stopped and see me and don’t expect me to stop. And I tell you that you are a piece of shit.
That’s all I’m done.
July 1st, 2008 at 9:02 pm
Jack, I’m sorry I called you a piece of shit. That wasn’t called for and the truth is you probably aren’t a piece of shit. I’m just super sensitive on this topic and flew off the handle a few hours ago. The other poo comments were jokes. Again, sorry.
July 26th, 2008 at 11:26 pm
Well, hopefully, the city of Atlanta can at least be thankful for your environmental friendliness by not adding to the fuel consumption and leaving your all’s carbon footprint by riding bikes (hey, don’t the Atlanta police have police bicyclists like here in Texas?!)!
September 23rd, 2008 at 12:39 pm
As a Ponsey Highland resident and recreational bike rider, I disagree with the Critical Mass riders. By breaking the traffic laws, you are eliminating any sympathy you might have for your cause with city officials who would make safety improvements to the streets for bicyclists. Although you may enlighten the pub crowd, I’m sure motorists and other onlookers have a much different reaction to your stunts. You use the mob mentality to be able to intimidate others. The police are doing their job in reacting to complaints from citizens about people ‘disturbing the peace’ and breaking traffic laws. If you guys observed the laws on your bike rides, like the ‘Critical Manners’ bike group, we wouldn’t be having this discussion, and police would be able to use their thin resources in other areas, like my neighborhood. I would suggest using a lawful means of advancing your cause like so many other groups do. That would legitimize your cause and evoke a positive reaction by all.
September 23rd, 2008 at 12:55 pm
Kyle, have you been on one of the Courteous Mass (as we call it ’round these parts, not Critical Manners) rides? I rode in the first two, and frankly, I didn’t see any shift toward the positive in the reactions evoked. We had cars cutting in haphazardly because we didn’t have any contiguity to the group, and after a couple of red lights the “mass” was so fractured into tiny bits that any “advancing the cause” visibility was pretty useless.
So we disagree.
October 2nd, 2008 at 12:32 pm
You claim to be out for a friendly ride, breaking laws is ok because you only do it a couple of hours a month, what happens when someone not paying attention comes through that intersection on the green light , as you bikers run the red.
Why not each give a dollar to ride, get a permit, hire a couple of those guys on the motorcyles to make it safe for everyone , and then fly through the streets safely and enjoy it. Or everyone give two dollars and do some bicyle charity give aways and repairs for kids. Make this a positive event, not something negative as it appears to be heading